Media have lost their minds with this ‘Lin-sanity’ business

Justice B. Hill

Not sure what to make of the public’s reaction to guard Jeremy Lin. In the post-racial world of President Barack Obama, Americans have become “racial” on some many fronts, which once looked as if it might be a good thing. “Lin-sanity,” however, has shown us otherwise

In fact, the media’s love affair with Lin, an undrafted player from Harvard, has demonstrated it’s best to discard “racial” and substitute the word “racist.” For surely a racist mindset has trumped common sense when it comes to how the media — or some in the public — view Lin, a 23-year-old Asian-American who has made a splash in the NBA.

Lin’s spectacular play for the New York Knicks has led to an insensitive tweet by Jason Whitlock, the empty-headed, race-baiting sports columnist for Fox Sports, and to a headline for ESPN that defies common sense. Whitlock has cultivated his stupidity. The man’s made a handsome living speaking out of his rear-end and disrespecting a legion of minorities, sports figures and public personalities. Whitlock is what he is — a court jester.

Yet as indefensible as Whitlock’s tweet was, it pales in comparison to a headline that slipped through the editing process at ESPN. Someone, and ESPN has refused to name the someone, wrote this headline: “Chink in the Armor.” To some, the expression might seem harmless. But to think it does is to be so removed from the reality of race as to be someone from another planet. The word “chink” has long been a derogatory term for Asians, and any adult with a college education should know as much.

So the headline cost one ESPN employee his (or her?) job. But what about the editing process that got the headline posted in the first place? Shouldn’t ESPN have had a safeguard in place, a system of checks-and-balances that should have prevented this from happening? If it did, how did the headline see light? Not one person erred; two erred, unless ESPN had no one to read a headline before it went live.

Richard Prince, who writes media column for the Maynard Institute, quoted Rebecca Carroll, a former managing editor at HuffPost Black Voices, as posting on her Facebook page: “How this headline was able to post in the first place is among the most poignant examples of the click-driven, exploitative and editor-less direction in which ‘web journalism’ has taken us. Sigh.”

Carroll was right. Ever since speed became the currency of online journalism, copy editors and producers have been under increasing pressure to be first and be provocative. Cleverness and speed matter more than anything else. No one wants to be second; no one wants to be boring either.

Sadly, this isn’t the first time ESPN, for all the good it does, has stepped outside the lines. It won’t be the last time either. In fact, in dealing with Lin, the network committed three acts of callous, inappropriate journalism. As Rob King, ESPN.com editor-in-chief, said in a tweet: “There’s no defense for the indefensible.” King, too, is right.

But to be overly critical of King and his ESPN editing staff wouldn’t be altogether fair. For the problem of immediacy at all cost isn’t unique to his ESPN staff; the problem is common to digital journalism. The safeguards that often marked sports journalism of yesteryear have vanished, given way to posting stories now and fixing ‘em later. Sloppiness, insensitivity, inaccuracy and incompleteness are the calling cards of sports journalism today.

Dewey Defeats Truman” in The Chicago Tribune, well … this error is worst. Although less historical, the Lin headline shows a mindset lacking a perspective; it also shows the danger of pushing hard for cleverness and for speed over all else.

Such errors in judgment are inexcusable. More heads should go. One firing and a suspension simply aren’t enough. ESPN should also put an editing strategy in place that, while pushing for speed, doesn’t give short-shrift to accuracy.

At bottom, sports journalism is the truth business. But sports journalism is also about showing class and taste, and no one can find much class in putting a tasteless slur on public display.

767 Comments

  1. James M. Rutland

    It certainly is nearly extremely difficult to find well-aware men and women on this content, unfortunately you seem like you realize what you’re indicating! Many Thanks
    James M. Rutland http://www.98kupd.mobi

  2. Patricia W. Evans

    It really is nearly not possible to find well-updated americans on this theme, unfortunately you look like you realize those things you’re talking about! Bless You
    Patricia W. Evans http://www.cheapspringbreaktrips2014.com

  3. Martha C. Brockway

    You’ll find it almost extremely difficult to find well-updated americans on this theme, however , you look like you know those things you’re raving about! Regards
    Martha C. Brockway http://www.teenbodybuilding.co

  4. Russell W. Person

    It is actually nearly unattainable to see well-qualified americans on this niche, yet somehow you come across as like you comprehend what exactly you’re revealing! Many Thanks
    Russell W. Person http://www.nyunus.com

  5. Lincoln C. Finch

    It certainly is near impossible to find well-advised visitors on this issue, unfortunately you seem like you are familiar with those things you’re writing about! With Thanks
    Lincoln C. Finch http://www.womensphere2013.com

  6. Richard L. Lemay

    It’s actually nearly close to impossible to find well-advised men or women on this subject, however, you seem like you realize exactly what you’re posting on! Thank You
    Richard L. Lemay http://www.extra-ordinaryfilm.com

  7. Robyn D. Alexander

    You’ll find it almost not possible to find well-qualified women and men on this issue, however you come across as like you fully grasp the things that you’re revealing! Excellent
    Robyn D. Alexander http://www.springbreakdealsforstudents2014.com

  8. Arturo E. Roper

    You’ll find it practically unthinkable to find well-aware viewers on this area, but you look like you be aware of which you’re preaching about! Gratitude
    Arturo E. Roper http://www.98kupd.mobi

  9. Patricia M. Porter

    It can be mostly unattainable to find well-educated viewers on this issue, still you look like you fully grasp the things you’re covering! Excellent
    Patricia M. Porter http://www.electricmultiverses.info

  10. Laura M. Erdman

    It is actually almost not possible to come across well-advised individual on this area, however you seem like you are familiar with exactly what you’re raving about! Appreciation
    Laura M. Erdman http://www.turksmr.org

  11. www.widewallpapers.us

    The system is fully-adjustable, having 360 degree amazing rotation attribute for landscape and portrait views.
    About The Cydia site, choose the DOWNLOAD BUNDLES button at the very top.

    Read the available Wi Fi network connections.

  12. Robert A. Silvey

    It is actually practically not possible to find well-informed individual on this issue, then again you seem like you comprehend whatever you’re preaching about! Regards
    Robert A. Silvey http://www.00000tv.com

  13. Patricia W. Evans

    It can be almost impossible to find well-advised individual on this subject, still, you come across as like you be aware of the things you’re talking about! Gratitude
    Patricia W. Evans http://www.cheapspringbreaktrips2014.com

  14. Ramon N. Zuniga

    It really is nearly unattainable to see well-educated women and men on this content, yet somehow you appear like you fully understand what you’re indicating! Appreciate It
    Ramon N. Zuniga http://www.redstoneenergygroup.us

  15. Robyn D. Alexander

    It certainly is mostly not possible to find well-updated people on this area, still, you come across as like you fully grasp what exactly you’re indicating! Regards
    Robyn D. Alexander http://www.springbreakdealsforstudents2014.com

  16. Tecca International

    I need to to thank you for this very good read!! I absolutely loved every bit of it. I have got you book-marked to check out new stuff you post…

  17. click the next website

    I’m amazed, I have to admit. Seldom do I come across a blog that’s both equally educative and entertaining, and let me tell you, you’ve hit the nail on the head. The problem is something which too few folks are speaking intelligently about. I’m very happy I stumbled across this in my search for something relating to this.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>


Warning: call_user_func_array() [function.call-user-func-array]: First argument is expected to be a valid callback, 'echo_tweets_js' was given in /home/content/25/5535425/html/justice/wp-includes/plugin.php on line 406